Passing on the Flag
In 2024, the Nexus Institute celebrated its thirtieth birthday. For this special occasion, we invited old and new friends of Nexus to write a letter to the younger generation, ‘passing on the flag’ of what they think really matters. The seventh part in the Cultura Animi series offers a rich collection of passionate pleas for the perpetuation of the critical spirit, the values of the classics, the quest for truth as an absolute precondition of political liberty, for freedom of thought, the value of peace, diplomacy and a healthy planet, of music and of tolerance. To you, the reader, falls the task of carrying the flag onwards!
Membership
Support the Nexus Institute by becoming a Nexus member. Subscribe now and receive a copy of Cultura Animi III, Becoming Human Is an Art as a welcome gift. Find out more and join.
Index
Lectori Salutem
Translation Liz Waters
In September 1994 the Nexus Instituut was founded so that as an institute, with broader opportunities than simply the journal Nexus, founded in 1991, it could do justice to the aim expressed in the first sentence of Nexus 1: ‘Every era requires its own cultural criticism, but for all eras criticism is a variation on the same theme: how to preserve the treasures that the human mind has produced and procured over the centuries.’
The Flag of Tolerance
As a survivor of Auschwitz, Dita Kraus knows the face of intolerance. How is it possible, she wonders, that there is so much hostility and intolerance in the world? Why is it that we always tend to distinguish between people, even though, in the end, we are all human? Kraus advocates for more recognition and compassion for all that lives on our planet.
So let us all be more tolerant and modest. Let us educate generations of men and women so that they will not let themselves be drawn into wars and murder by power-thirsty individuals. Let us educate generations of moderate, reasonable and helpful individuals. Men and women who are able to think by themselves, who wouldn’t be influenced by propaganda and slogans.
The Flag of Freedom
Translation Katie Assef
Over the course of the twentieth century, many left-wing thinkers in France felt the attraction of communism. Raymond Aron was one of the few French intellectuals who was critical of this trend, and continuously drew attention to the totalitarianism that often lay behind those lofty political ideals. This did not earn him much admiration. It took courage, writes Aron's daughter Dominique Schnapper in her contribution to Nexus, to confront the hostility and contempt of the conformists in the cultural institutions of the West. Freedom and truth, according to Schnapper, are not just ideas, but must be actively pursued with courage and sincerity.
The lesson of the twentieth century must never be forgotten. Freedom is never a given, it is never achieved once and for all; it is always the product of a determined will that must be renewed from one generation to the next. Young friends: have the courage to be unpopular and to be marginalized. In doing so, you will give meaning to your life. We are passing you the torch. Don’t be afraid.
Letter to a Young Philosopher
According to Allan Janik, a true philosopher does not choose philosophy, but is assigned this fate. This he writes in his letter to a young 'Hypatia', who has doubts about her study. Janik himself had his first philosophical experience when, as an eleven-year-old boy, he looked in the mirror and asked himself the basic epistemological question: 'how do I know that what I see is me'? And after reading a history of philosophy four years later, he knew for certain: this was what he was meant to do. What did Janik learn about the profession in the decades that have followed since?
To be a real philosopher is a lot more than being a good student of philosophy, accumulating knowledge of the subject’s various branches and history […], it is a matter of using the knowledge that one has acquired of the functioning of epistemological and moral concepts to illuminate the genuine perplexities that stymie sophisticated scientist or gifted artists as well as ordinary agents in their efforts to master the conundrums studded on life’s way.
Letter to a Young Humanist
Translation Will Schutt
Anyone who has ever been a student in the humanities will be familiar with the question: 'What can you do with that?' It takes courage and tenacity, writes classicist Andrea Marcolongo, to dedicate yourself to the humanities in this day and age. Culture cannot be compared to a screwdriver; you cannot assign a concrete purpose or practical application to it in the same way, but that is precisely why it is significant. The task of these sciences is not, Marcolongo argues, to do something with it, but rather to give meaning to everything we do.
The classics offer us an irreplaceable vision of existence, crystallized in the jade of their ancient alphabets, developed by heroic peoples who lived 25 centuries before us and yet faced the same problems and dilemmas that you and I and billions of other people are experiencing today. What is the meaning of life and death? How do we endure pain? What are the ethical limits of laws? Should innovation be pursued no matter the moral cost? And so on and so forth, with all the questions that enable us to build a free and dignified humanist future without looking ahead with anguish and irrationality.
Letter to a Young Musician
In a loving letter to her eight-year-old daughter, pianist Tamar Halperin reflects on the value of classical music, modern music and art in general. As time goes on, tastes, styles and languages inevitably change – it is pointless to resist that. But what characterizes the great artists of the past and the present, Halperin argues, is precisely their ability to produce something eternal, to express something that transcends the whims of the moment.
At your very young age you already know this much: that we can learn about the world from the art of great masters. Because what is the purpose of art, ultimately, if not to crystallize some profound truth about the world, about human nature, to which we can relate?
The Flag of Knowledge
Translation Katie Assef
How can a country survive in a time of social change and division? According to Caroline Noirot, director of the Parisian publishing house Les Belles Lettres, knowledge of the classical literary heritage is essential to navigate today's world. The 'will to know', according to Noirot, together with a critical mind and imagination, are essential to transcend the boundaries of the existing and thus build a future of freedom and fraternity.
According to Heraclitus, you can never step into the same river twice. In other words, everything is constantly changing, the water as much as the swimmer. Ancient texts have an unusual power of irrigation; they are not traces of a vanished past, but bearers of promise. They are the banks that allow the river to flow. Level the banks, and the river turns to dead water.
The Flag of Diplomacy
After the fall of the Berlin Wall, the demise of communism, and the 'return to Europe' of the former Eastern Bloc countries, the future of liberal democracy seemed to be assured forever. Today, little remains of the optimism with which the millennium began. Where did it all go wrong? What could we have done better? And what lessons should a young diplomat learn today to face the world of tomorrow with confidence?
Carrying the flame of diplomacy in 2024? Is it a utopian goal when war is raging, from Ukraine to Gaza, from Myanmar to Sudan? Is it a priority when raw power reigns supreme, and when the priority is to balance power with power rather than to explore pathways to peace?
The Flag of Classical Music
In one of his plays, Shakespeare writes about a poet, 'Tear him to pieces for his bad verses!' Nowadays, 'bad verses' dominate our public space in the form of bad music, according to David Dubal. In this fiery Philippic – addressed to a young musician at risk of entering the world of rock music – classical pianist David Dubal rails against the rise of a contemporary kitsch culture and encourages his readers to reconsider the value of beauty.
I beseech you to stay with your art, deprivation and all. If you will not, your sleep will forever be haunted by that mysterious chemistry of the artistic mind, which will become dormant. If you are not true to yourself your talents will rot.
Conversation with a Young Writer
What would you like to say to your past self if you had the chance? In this personal text, Elif Shafak paints a picturesque account of the dialogue between herself and a certain young female novelist, who struggles with the profession and with the limited freedom she experiences in her native Turkey. Being a writer will not become easier, is Shafak's honest message, but the beauty she creates will live on too.
It is an infinite space, Storyland. A way of connecting beyond borders. Literature has the ability to rehumanise those who have been dehumanised, to make the invisible a bit more visible, to bring the periphery to the centre, to empower the disempowered. Inside Storyland there is no ‘us’ versus ‘them’. There is no ‘Other’.
Letter to the Young
In a poignant and moving letter, Ray Monk announces that he does not have long to live. He feels all the more urgently his duty to stand up for everything he believes in and to pass on his beliefs to future generations. His main message: escape the destructive rule of big money and recognize the value of what really matters: a healthy, happy and fulfilling life in harmony with the natural world, and everything that belongs to it.
In the short time that is left to me I want to feed the soul by listening to more music, reading more literature, appreciating more works of art and visiting more fine works of architecture. Above all, I want to work with others to achieve the transformation of values necessary for humanity itself to live a good life.